Why I Would Not Sign Brett Favre
No one is debating if Brett Favre is a great, if not Hall Of Fame, quarterback. Fans, football professionals and media people will be talking about him whenever the subject of QB’s come up. I think because he played in the harsh weather in Green Bay, it makes what he has done even more impressive. After a crap-tastic season last year, they came within one play of going to the Super Bowl. Everyone expected Brett to come out the next year and go beat the crap out of everyone after he seemingly re-lit his fire.
Then he made that proverbial left turn at Albequerque.
After rumors kept swirling, he decided to retire. In a teary statement he said he just didn’t have it in him anymore. At 39 years old he felt like he was finished, and no one was blaming him, he’s had a helluva career (I’ll spare you the stats). When a man cries on worldwide television, we tend to take him at his word. However, a lot of sports guys said he would be back.
The Packers, running thier business, looked to thier backup QB Aaron Rodgers. Aaron isn’t awesome, he has barely played and when he has, well, it was not spectacular. But it was what they had and they dealt with it. You move on. Moving on doesn’t mean forgetting about Brett, but you have to focus on the road ahead. Football is a business.
Then training camp comes and everyone is soooo surprised that Brett is talking about playing again. Of course he is. He has been playing professional football for almost 20 years, and add to that college, high school and peewee-whatever-kids football, that brings up up to almost 35 years of training at the same time every year. Muscle memory would make you long for camp, for training, for getting back onto the field. I’m sure he loves his wife and his kids but I think football is that 3rd love. The one that’s always there for you.
So he wants to play. Some people say that Green Bay should bring him back in to the fold with open arms, but honestly, I would not. And I do not think the Packers should either, here are a few reasons why:
1. Would he pull this crap next year?
Ok so let’s say the Packers have another “missed it by that much” season. Who’s to say that he won’t get frustrated and decide to “retire” again after this coming season? Then you have to deal with this all over again, which, by the way, is an A+ PR nightmare.
2. What about Aaron Rodgers?
The Packers have been grooming Rodgers for years to take over for Favre. Now you want the organization to walk right in and tell him, after months of stating they are with him, that he’s back to Banana #2? That’s not going to build much faith between him and the team. It’s blatantly unfair. Some people have said that football is not fair and Rodgers should deal with it. Yes, Football is not fair, but a man’s word is a man’s word. Going back on that sends a message to the whole team that says “you are replaceable at any time no matter how hard you work”. That, my friends, is bullshit. And again, also a PR nightmare.
Brett says he’s been hurt by stories planted, by things people have said, but the problem lays with him. If he wanted to come back he should have said it sooner, before all the talk of who is the starter. Rodgers has a tough road ahead of him, a lot like Garcia after the glory years of Montana and Young. I doubt he will perform like Young ended up playing after taking over, but I guess we will see.
Farve can end his career like a lot of fantastic QB’s: Montana ended in Kansas City and Namath finished in San Diego. I have a feeling, however, he will end up on television, hopefully replacing Troy Aikman who is the suckiest broadcaster who ever did suck.